• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
bfpeople

bfpeople

Recruitment, Assessment, Development

  • Home
  • Leadership
    recruitment
  • Leadership
    assessment
  • Leadership
    development
  • Leadership
    judgement
  • About
    bfpeople
  • News & Views
  • Contact
Why is it so hard to recruit good candidates?

Why is it so hard to recruit good candidates?

John Hamilton 1st March 2016 Filed Under: recruitment

Despite the economic uncertainty, some notable business failures in the industry and the vast increase in candidate registrations on CV database websites, many organizations find it difficult to attract and recruit good candidates.

This is nothing new.  Companies have always had to compete for the best, but there was a time, when I started as a recruiter, that a display advert in the national, local or trade press would provide a solid field of good candidates for most vacancies. Now however, despite the plethora of choices for online advertising and the increasing “connectedness” of our LinkedIn world, creating a strong shortlist for many roles can be a challenge.  A lot of talented employees aren’t actively looking for a new role: they’re busy, keeping their head down and, more than likely, being well looked after by their current employer. They have to be confident that any new opportunity is not too big a risk.

To improve your chances of attracting great candidates, consider the following as a starting point:

1: Your employer brand – you don’t have to be a household name business to attract top talent. Great candidates join start-ups and small, unknown companies, attracted by the opportunity presented to them, the flexible working environment, benefits, or the reputation the business has for looking after and developing people. Big or small, what’s your brand and reputation as an employer? There are some big brands that have poor reputations as employers or are considered to have cultures that put candidates off. Big or small, what’s your brand and reputation as an employer?

2: Your recruitment process – your advertising, job description, application process and correspondence with candidates should be compelling, informative and user-friendly. Unless the role is one that will attract high numbers of candidates, don’t create processes that mark it hard for people to apply and filters that weed out people too quickly.

Is your website, jobs page and application process optimised for mobile? With many busy candidates looking at jobs from their phone, you need to make it easy for them to apply – few have CVs readily available on their phone. 

3. Your job marketing/search activity – most successful candidates for our projects come from word of mouth, targeted advertising campaigns or direct approaches to them. They don’t come from job boards or CV databases. Many of the most interesting people we engage with are not “actively” looking and so not on the radar of other recruiters and employers. Social media has its place, but is not the Holy Grail for recruitment: there are lots of very talented people who are not on LinkedIn! Think hard about where your best candidates might be and how to reach out to them.

4. Your salary level – while money isn’t everything, an average salary is unlikely to attract star performers. Research the market and consider how you can persuade good people to make the move. Paying the “going rate” for the job will generally only attract people who are a step or two below the level you’re looking to hire at. That’s fine if you want someone who is stepping up to your role, but not helpful if you need a proven quantity at that level. If you can’t compete on salary, look for other ways to make the job attractive to someone who might move sideways e.g. flexible benefits, a performance bonus, extra holidays and working from home.

5. Interviewing skills – I’ve seen many good candidates lose interest after a badly conducted interview by the employer. Good recruitment interviewing is a skill that takes time, and experience, to do well. The balance of power has shifted in interviews – candidates are often far more prepared (and usually far more rehearsed) for the meeting than the interviewer. Poor questioning skills, even worse listening skills and little understanding of the job and its requirements are common errors among company interviewers. Badly conducted interviews don’t just put off really good candidates, they also result in bad hiring decisions, where the wrong applicant is appointed. Make sure your interviewers are trained, prepared and able to sell your opportunity to candidates.

If you offer challenging, rewarding jobs and get these basics right you have a good chance of attracting top quality talent to keep you ahead of the game.

An edited version of this article first appeared in Retail Focus magazine

You may also like

Are your interview questions a strength or a weakness?
Recruitment Lessons from the Scottish Referendum
The truth about "great" interview questions
Creating a talent pool

Footer

Popular pages

  • First 90 days coaching programme – hit the ground running
  • Executive Search & Recruitment – finding leaders
  • Our global recruitment network
  • Career Coaching – exploring your options at work
  • Take the Leadership Judgement Indicator
  • The Leadership Judgement Indicator

Featured links

  • Leadership coaching topics: the most common leadership challenges
  • BFP Fast Track – no risk, fixed fee recruitment
  • Business acquisition search
  • Leadership Assessment and Psychometric Testing
  • Your leadership style: the key to succeeding as a manager

Contact us

0333 202 2225 - all enquiries
0141 280 2680 - Glasgow
01332 565125 - Derby
020 7717 5070 - London

bfpeople is a Cyber Essentials certified company

Cyber essential badge

Search this site:

Copyright © 2020 bfpeople | All rights reserved | privacy policy | website terms of use